When I read about this on the Blonde forum a few weeks ago, my initials thoughts (which still stand) are that online poker has just dealt itself a massive blow. At a time when the online poker market is booming, there are so many people who question it"s integrity (recent UB scandal etc), and by effectively banning winning, this is potentially suicidal for what could and should be a highly lucrative market.
I understand the principal of needing to remain attractive to weaker players, BUT if a new player comes along and is considering starting playing online, but hears that if he wins he will be banned, I wonder whether he will bother.
Also, surely to have a pool of losing players, simple maths says you have to have the flipside of the equation, ie winning players.
Ridiculous situation.