Hey John,
I played in a tournament with a similar structure at the Vic (not my local so only played it the once). Most casinos up and down the country don"t have well structured daily or weekly tournaments - although I believe Luton Grosvenor is one expception, I"m sure Tightend can confirm - but I guess there"s only so much any live venue can do for a one night comp.
But, after my experience in not only this comp but other local comps I got to thinking that perhaps players, like myself, who have learnt via the internet have been spoiled structure wise by this learning ground. In stt"s and mtt"s on a site like stars you (mostly) get the same number of chips to start with regardless of buy-in and you normally have around 150 BBs in your starting stack (e.g Stars 18k gtd 3000 chips, blinds 10/20) and in the fact that a 15 minute level online equates to about 30 minutes live and also that most casino comps are self-dealt and it"s no wonder that online is so popular (lob in multi tabling too).
I had a conversation along these lines with Richard, Tikay and Des in Caridff at the APAT and, lets be honest the APAT is a godsend for players who want to play a good structured live comp with an affordable buy-in.
Yet, and I don"t know what it"s like in your local casino but in Bristol, until recently, the most popular comps were the £10 re-buys, which got considerably more runners than a £20-£50 freezeout competition. Luckily we have a popular meetup poker group in Bristol that organises and runs well structured, friendly home games where you can play poker.
Casinos, for the most part do need to up their game comp wise, because whilst they will always attract new customers and those who detest online, or prefer live over online, once new players become advance newcomers and become more structure savvy then IMO there"s only one winner. Hopf when the new laws kick in we"ll see some improvements such as being able to double re-buy at the beginning of a re-buy, late registration in comps and others which I know Grosvenor are considering implementing (they can"t at the moment due to the laws).
Wow, that turned into a bit of a rant, wasn"t meant to be!